this is fucking great

I'm not a pet person - at all. But I'm in absolute lust with this pet. As soon as I'm able to I will be getting a NM Charlie. Whoever drew this (?) should be immensely proud of themselves. This is beyond amazing.

... swoon

That Smile

omg i want one

Awesome!

I looove this. o:

this is amazing! best one so far :D

i really want to make an overlay and just move his finger over so hes flipping everyone off XD

I cant express how much I love this, because this is mind blowing awesome! If I get another pet in the future, it's gonna be this one. Not a fan of Charlies, but I am a HUGE fan of this one!!

That is so amazing.
Just..Oh my God.
Mind = BLOWN on this one.
Whoever drew this is of epic proportions.

bestest nightmare ever :)

I've been waiting for the perfect nightmare pet to turn Wistful into.
I think we have a winner!

This Charlie is so amazing. <3 Words can not describe how wonderful this is! Kudos to the artist!

I've been waiting for the perfect nightmare pet to turn Wistful into.
I think we have a winner!

This Charlie is so amazing. <3 Words can not describe how wonderful this is! Kudos to the artist!

Amazing!!!

First Charlie that has the certain unique charme of that species since the GY one!
Love it! It's all like "Come to daddy!" XD

I must be the only one who doesn't find this that awesome. Good work anyway!

omg! so cute :). I really want one!

whoa awesome!

Awwwww cuuuutie!!

I like that :D

I don't like Charlies. I don't like Nightmare pets.
But OMG that is one EPIC scary looking pet! :o Great job on the art!

This is so cute x_x

Most. Adorable. Charlie. Ever.

Awesome :)
But I hope they'll release Nightmare Tigreans soon (and if I dont like them I believe Mordor will become a Nightmare Charlie)!

is it wrong that I find this really cute?

Well hello new favorite pet! Awesome!

Love it! Especially the teeth/smile wow.

Ohdarn that tummy!! ;w; I love this thing and I don't even like charlies mygoodnesswhat THANK YOU SUBETA (artist, you rock!)! ♥️

Woah, look at that ;o; I love it!

Aww... I think I'm in love ___

Awseome job!!! Maybe, I'm going to make one

Oh my goodness that's fantabulous @-@

Holy love-muffin, I am so tempted to get that Charlie. D;

OMG _

did anyone think of, "Hi giiiiiirls~?" oh sweet celestia of molestia D:

Got mine! Bastages is now a nightmare Charlie!!

Most awesome Charlie ever, I really love the teeth! ^_^
Good job to the artist!

Holy crap! That....is.....AWESOME!!!
Reminds me of cage creed. "I got something for you mommy"

This pet is beyond amazing!

I love the looks of this pet!

I CHANGE MY MIND.
I JUST HAD A NIGHTMARE INVOLVING THIS THING.
D:

This is the most amazing thing.

So bad ass!

OMG, I love this! The right mixture of creepy and adorable!

Damn son. I really kind of want it

Oh. My. Gawd!!! I KNEW I was saving that nightmare potion for a reason!!! :P He is awesome!!! Love the beckoning paw....

YAY NIGHTMARES!

Oh. My. God.
This. Is simply perfect.
And I'm not even a fan of Charlie.
...Definitely gonna get me another pet slot.

Also, I want to see someone edit this to look like Stitch. That would be a perfect overlay.

THAT IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL PET I HAVE EVER SEEN.