topizots
Ugh, the first revamp I prefer BIG time. I liked the curly chest/fluff, now there isn't enough! I loved the ear tufts. This revamp, I do not like the head at all. OK, I am NEVER negative, this is my first complaint on subeta and I feel bad but have to be honest. This revamp is not favorable to me. <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_sad.gif border=0>
I think that if the first one didn't have the crazy chest fluff, it would be perfect. XD And wow, the poll is really close this time. o__O
just saw Arda's retouch of the first revamp...<br />
with that one the tilted head would no longer bother me. laughts anyway...<br />
as i said, voted 2 because of the changes ^^ even with the thicker nose and somehow changed muzzle. XD
with that one the tilted head would no longer bother me. laughts anyway...<br />
as i said, voted 2 because of the changes ^^ even with the thicker nose and somehow changed muzzle. XD
I actually like how the tuft was fixed and is now less fluffy. It looks good to me. Definately revamp 2 ftw. <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_smile.gif border=0>
<b>Quote:</b><blockquote style="padding:5px; line-height:15px; background-color: #FAFFFF; border: 1px solid #000000; font-family: georgia; font-size: 10;">thing I thought....revamp one for female tigereans, revamp 2 for males...not that they'll ever do something like that but hey its what I think</blockquote>
Asking them to draw a look for female and male pets it is a bit hard on the artists isn't it?
Because some pets have no gender because thry may be elixired former atebus pets.
Also then people might gripe and say my pets don't have the option of a look for the male and a look for the female.
The artists haven't even finished doing all the versions of some recent revamps in special colors.
They have alot of work on them already plus I am sure they have actual lives to live outside of Subeta, but yeah only my opinion.
Asking them to draw a look for female and male pets it is a bit hard on the artists isn't it?
Because some pets have no gender because thry may be elixired former atebus pets.
Also then people might gripe and say my pets don't have the option of a look for the male and a look for the female.
The artists haven't even finished doing all the versions of some recent revamps in special colors.
They have alot of work on them already plus I am sure they have actual lives to live outside of Subeta, but yeah only my opinion.
firstt thing I thought....revamp one for female tigereans, revamp 2 for males...not that they'll ever do something like that but hey its what I think
Revamp 2 definitelly. It is less fluffy. Head has better position althoug it still has not as long body as old version. But is nicer than 1st.
Ears and chest area = better.
The nose seems so wide shrugs.
Tail tip still looks broken to me (the way it hangs down) and the front legs do seem a bit thick. Maybe thinning the front leg would leave room for the tail tip to be adjusted into a different position?
I really think it is great for the artists to take comments into consideration <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_smile.gif border=0> it makes the site that much more likable!
The nose seems so wide shrugs.
Tail tip still looks broken to me (the way it hangs down) and the front legs do seem a bit thick. Maybe thinning the front leg would leave room for the tail tip to be adjusted into a different position?
I really think it is great for the artists to take comments into consideration <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_smile.gif border=0> it makes the site that much more likable!
I like original to be honest. I think the pose of the original one looks the best. It gives it a more "feline" aspect of a cat that slinks and stalks.
I chose revamp #1. Even though I don't have a tigrean, I still chose number 1. I just really like that tuft of hair on it's chest.
"I didn't think the shading was a problem on the old revamp, though"
I also feel that if the shading was kept the same (ie the darker tones), alot more people would prefer version 2 over 1.
At least version 2 fixed the locks/cowlick.
thumbs up to the artists
I also feel that if the shading was kept the same (ie the darker tones), alot more people would prefer version 2 over 1.
At least version 2 fixed the locks/cowlick.
thumbs up to the artists
User not found:
<i> Poor artists, catering to the finnicky and inconsistent whims of Subetans....but I do like the version in my art gallery (a modification of the first revamp) a lot better than either of these.
I didn't think the shading was a problem on the old revamp, though. And the teeny little cowlick this version has...well, I just don't get it. The old Tigrean didn't have a cowlick/tuft of any kind.
</i>
I didn't think the shading was a problem on the old revamp, though. And the teeny little cowlick this version has...well, I just don't get it. The old Tigrean didn't have a cowlick/tuft of any kind.
</i>
To quote a famous fast food take away: "I'm loving it!"
It's yum!
Thanks for taking the previous comments into consideration! Thanks especially for loosing the locks! <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_grin.gif border=0>
Just one further suggestion (and will probably resolve the "fat legs" look) if you use the darker shading as in the first revamp (for example by the left rear leg's shin and thigh, and on the front left leg), the legs may look a little more muscular.
It's yum!
Thanks for taking the previous comments into consideration! Thanks especially for loosing the locks! <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_grin.gif border=0>
Just one further suggestion (and will probably resolve the "fat legs" look) if you use the darker shading as in the first revamp (for example by the left rear leg's shin and thigh, and on the front left leg), the legs may look a little more muscular.
User not found:
They should both the new ones.
The front paw that's sticking out looks a little... fat? and the head looks as if something more could've been done to it.
Chalk me up as someone that likes the head posing better; sometimes they look awkward with a craned head. My only complaints are that it needs a little more of a neck, it sits too far near the shoulders, and the lineart on the face needs to be touched up (looks blurry to me too). Otherwise, I like the new revamp version a lot.
User not found:
Ah <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_grin.gif border=0>
This revamp has swayed my vote from the old tigrean. The ears, chest and tail look much better <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_smile.gif border=0>
I have to say, I think with this revamp the tigrean would continue to be my favourite Subeta pet.
Great work to the artist, can't wait to see what Darkmatter will look like :3
This revamp has swayed my vote from the old tigrean. The ears, chest and tail look much better <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_smile.gif border=0>
I have to say, I think with this revamp the tigrean would continue to be my favourite Subeta pet.
Great work to the artist, can't wait to see what Darkmatter will look like :3
I like both of the revamps, though I must say that the front legs on both are too close togeather. I love the entire head on the first revamp aside for its' left ear which seems a little thin, but that might just be me. But I like the body better on revamp 2. I like the shading better on it, its not as dark, also I like that you do away with that random fluff. The first its sort of like, fluff and then cut. However, I will vote for the first one because the head makes up for most of these errors. Good work artists and sorry for being harsh.
User not found:
Sorry for the double-post.
User not found:
Still voted for the old one, because of the pose (it wasn't on a single plane, maybe that's why it's more interesting) and the way the tail is... but I do prefer this one to the first revamp.
User not found:
Still voted for the old one, because of the pose (it wasn't on a single plain, maybe that's why it's more interesting) and the way the tail is... but I do prefer this one to the first revamp.
I like the body and less fluff on this one, but...I like the way the head and face are in revamp 1 much better.
User not found:
I really like the body of the new revamped tigrean. Much more alive than the old one, but something with the face and brows reminds of of neaderthal-ish. x.x
Sorry, but yeah... it just looks odd to me. But i love the body!! And can't wait for the final version, the poor tigrean definitely needed a revamp!
Sorry, but yeah... it just looks odd to me. But i love the body!! And can't wait for the final version, the poor tigrean definitely needed a revamp!
User not found:
I didn't like the fluff on revamp 1, and I think it looks a lot better without the fur tufts for some reason and the pose isn't so....magestic(sp?) but the head has less face and the tail lost some of its sheen. I still voted for number 2 though. They are both a LOT better then the old one though. The old one was so plain. I think this revamp will get a lot more people to consider a Tigrean since the old one was so...plain.....
I still don't like the shading much for this revamp. The highlights I see seem to draw my attention way too easily. Also, the front legs seem off, though I can't pinpoint where. The art is lovely though. <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_grin.gif border=0> The lines and the design of the pet.
Hmmm....I had to go ahead and vote for revamp 1.After looking at them more I realised I liked it a whole lot better xP
User not found:
They're both nice but something about the legs is bothering me. It looks like it's stepping on itself, the front left...
The deciding factors for me was the face and the line of action. Revamp 1's line of action is much more graceful and the face is much more charming, more cunning. Because of the altered head position on revamp 2, we loose that graceful swerving action and the face is somewhat bland in the second one for some reason.
User not found:
I like revamp 2 better.
The puffiness of the chest fur on revamp 1 bothers me.
The puffiness of the chest fur on revamp 1 bothers me.
Nestly: Still like the first revamp better. x3 I think it looks snazzier with it's head turned the other way. ;3 Both good though.
The revamp 2 is much better in my opinion! votes <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_smile.gif border=0>
User not found:
this is hard! there are things i like about both... i think my only constructive criticism would be look of the penciled brows. on the first revamp, it looked furrowed, this one is a little caveman-like with the way it sort of droops. the head pose is a lot better, i must say. the first revamp looked a little vogue to me, haha. glad to see the curly fur was removed. the second revamp looks fierce! kudos to the artist!
Ok, so my opinion on these. I definitely love the re-draws much more than the original.
In redraw 1 I love the furry chest and the extra fur in the inner ears. He definitely looks sleeker and has more of a kind of superior pose to him that I don't like. I love the sleekness though. The main thing I didn't like was the head position.
In redraw 2 I love absolutely love the head position now. However you took away the furriness I liked from redraw 1. LOL. He is also thicker looking which is ok, I guess, but I liked the sleekness of redraw 1. The superiority head tilt is gone though so I'm voting for 2, just wish you kept the furry chest and ears <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_smile.gif border=0>
In redraw 1 I love the furry chest and the extra fur in the inner ears. He definitely looks sleeker and has more of a kind of superior pose to him that I don't like. I love the sleekness though. The main thing I didn't like was the head position.
In redraw 2 I love absolutely love the head position now. However you took away the furriness I liked from redraw 1. LOL. He is also thicker looking which is ok, I guess, but I liked the sleekness of redraw 1. The superiority head tilt is gone though so I'm voting for 2, just wish you kept the furry chest and ears <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_smile.gif border=0>
hehe, when I voted it was equal between one and two at 339 each <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_smile.gif border=0>
User not found:
There are things I like about both revamps, but the lack of the fluffy chest sealed my vote for number 2 <img src=http://www.subetax.org/images/smilies/6398_emoticon_raspberry.gif border=0>